Modern Authentication vs. Basic Authentication | Simplilearn (2024)

Identity and access management means everything to today’s modern networks, both public and private. Basic authentication, where usernames and passwords have traditionally been the key lines of defense, are no longer sufficient as a means to protect networks and internet applications that are increasingly relying on zero trust security protocol at the edge.

According to a recent Verizon data breach report, 82 percent of breaches involved some type of human element, including social engineering attacks, user errors, or general misuse. That is a primary reason that organizations are turning to a new generation of authentication called modern authentication.

Where Basic Authentication Falls Short

Basic authentication has its roots in accessing internet resources, where easy access for users is paramount. Usernames and passwords are stored in the Web header field in plain text with base64 encoding, using SSL to encrypt the headers and ensure user credentials are kept secure. The problem is that even when more secure HTTPS is used, basic authentication has several drawbacks and vulnerabilities.

  • Authentication headers can be seen for each access request, which makes it much easier for a bad actor to capture those user credentials.
  • Passwords are usually cached right in the browser, which introduces another vulnerable access vector.
  • Basic authentication isn’t able to limit grades of access permission, so one point of access to an application potentially opens up multiple avenues to all the data a user has access to. Users should have access only to the data needed for a particular function, nothing more.
  • Fundamentally, usernames and passwords are an antiquated and inadequate method of protecting vital data and information.

Making the Move to Modern Authentication

Modern authentication is a stronger method of identity management that provides more secure user authentication and access authorization. It allows a user access from a client device like a laptop or a mobile device to a server to obtain data or information. Modern authentication lets administrators tailor authentication policy to meet their access control requirements. Admins can configure access policies from a single, centralized location with modern authentication to account for all users, instead of having to configure access for every individual application where network access is needed.

Modern authentication follows a few basic tenets:

Continuous Authentication

Today’s technology users, such as for online banking or ATM transactions, demand a smooth and consistent user journey from beginning to end. Risk engines must analyze a wide range of data on the user, including location, device and even the cadence a user types in a keyboard to verify a user’s identity in real time.

Adaptive Authentication

A modern system can use shortcuts to verify user identities by allowing those who fit a low-risk profile to enter the network without adding additional user information. An example would be allowing users from a certain city where an HQ is located to access a network, whereas users from other locations would be asked for more information.

Become an Expert in the Cyber Security Field

Post Graduate Program In Cyber SecurityExplore Program

Modern Authentication vs. Basic Authentication | Simplilearn (2)

Attribute-based Access Controls

The system matches subject and object attributes, along with environment conditions with the access requirements that are outlined in specific access control rules. User characteristics must match or they are not allowed access.

Modern Authentication Protocols

Modern authentication uses established protocols that are designed to accommodate internet-scale applications and associated access control. They allow administrators to separate the identity provider (the entity that accepts credentials and validates who a user is) and the service provider (the entity providing the service a user is trying to access). And there is no requirement for direct communication between the identify and service providers.

Common modern authentication protocols include:

  • WS-Federation (Web Services Federation): Used to verify and authenticate a user across web-based services so that a user can stay authenticated across multiple applications. It’s commonly used with Microsoft Active Directory.
  • Security Authentication Markup Language (SAML): Connects the identity provider to the service provider and demands the verification of user credentials. It also gives more flexibility with determining who starts the authorization flow and how the encryption works.
  • Open Authorization (OAuth): As a delegation protocol, OAuth authorizes access to compatible sites once you’ve logged in to one site, such as signing into Facebook or Google to authenticate you for other partner sites.
  • OpenID Connect (OICD): Essentially a more formalized version of OAuth with agreed-upon minimum standards that major platforms must meet, allowing developers to move the authorization process to trusted agent platforms.

Microsoft Moving Deadline for Modern Authentication

The issue of companies moving to modern authentication has been in the news lately, as Microsoft anticipates retiring support for basic authentication on Exchange Online, putting pressure on admins to switch over to modern authentication methods. Microsoft announced on September 1, 2022 that customers will be able to re-enable basic authentication for selected protocols one time after the old October 1 deadline until the end of 2022, and it will permanently disable basic authentication for these protocols in the first week of January 2023.

Get help in becoming an industry-ready professional by enrolling in a unique Advanced Executive Program in Cybersecurity. Get valuable insights from industry leaders and enhance your interview skills. Enroll TODAY!

Keeping Skill Sets Current

Cyber security certifications like CISSP and CISM will be critical for network security administrators who will be under the gun to keep pace with big changes in identity and access management. It’s not too late to get a jump on these developments in a rapidly-growing IT industry.

Modern Authentication vs. Basic Authentication | Simplilearn (2024)

FAQs

What is the difference between basic authentication and modern authentication? ›

Making the Move to Modern Authentication

Modern authentication is a stronger method of identity management that provides more secure user authentication and access authorization. It allows a user access from a client device like a laptop or a mobile device to a server to obtain data or information.

Is Basic Authentication good enough? ›

Basic authentication is simple and convenient, but it is not secure. It should only be used to prevent unintentional access from nonmalicious parties or used in combination with an encryption technology such as SSL.

Which authentication method is better? ›

More Secure: Biometrics. Biometric authentication methods rely on something you are. That makes them hard to steal, difficult to misplace or share, and impossible to forget.

Why is OAuth better than basic authentication? ›

It's like choosing a secure, encrypted message over a shout across a crowded room. OAuth offers that essential layer of security and control, wrapping user credentials in a layer of armor that Basic Authentication simply can't match.

What are the three 3 main types of authentication? ›

There are three authentication factors that can be used: something you know, something you have, and something you are. Something you know would be a password, a PIN, or some other personal information.

What is the weakest authentication? ›

Passwords are considered to be the weakest form of the authentication mechanism because these password strings can be exposed easily by a dictionary attack. In this automated framework, potential passwords are guessed and matched by taking arbitrary words.

Is Basic Authentication outdated? ›

Furthermore, the enforcement of multifactor authentication (MFA) is not simple or in some cases, possible when Basic authentication remains enabled. Basic authentication is an outdated industry standard.

What is the strongest form of authentication? ›

Physical security key

A physical authentication key is one of the strongest ways to implement multifactor authentication. A private key, stored on a physical device, is used to authenticate a user, such as a USB device that a user plugs into their computer while logging in.

Which type of authentication is most secure? ›

1. Biometric Authentication Methods. Biometric authentication relies on the unique biological traits of a user in order to verify their identity. This makes biometrics one of the most secure authentication methods as of today.

What is the best authentication mode? ›

When choosing from among WEP, WPA, WPA2 and WPA3 wireless security protocols, experts agree WPA3 is best for Wi-Fi security. As the most up-to-date wireless encryption protocol, WPA3 is the most secure choice. Some wireless APs do not support WPA3, however.

Which type of authentication should you use? ›

Multi-factor authentication is preferred, as it is much more difficult for an intruder to overcome. With just a password, an attacker only has to have a single attack skill and wage a single successful attack to impersonate the victim.

Why is Basic Authentication generally not recommended? ›

The main problem with basic authentication is that credentials like passwords and usernames are sent as cleartext and are therefore vulnerable to packet sniffing. Standard authentication is straightforward and convenient, but it's not secure.

Why use JWT instead of Basic Auth? ›

JWT is preferred over any other authentication method because of certain distinct benefits it presents. Developers opt for JWT as these tokens are self-contained and don't ask for any effort to collect info about the user.

What is an example of modern authentication? ›

Modern authentication relies on multiple as well as strong factors such as biometrics to authenticate users with a combination of the following factors: Something the user knows: It could be a password, PIN, or pattern. Something the user has: It could be a security token, smartphone, or keycard.

What is the difference between types of authentication? ›

The difference between two things is the way in which they are unlike each other. There is no difference between the sexes. We do have problems here.

What is the difference between Basic Authentication and open authentication? ›

Opposed to OAuth, Basic Authentication is a more straightforward, yet less secure method embedded within the HTTP framework. It involves transmitting a username and password with every request, often encoded in Base64. This method, while simple, risks exposing user credentials more openly.

What is the Basic Authentication? ›

HTTP Basic authentication (BA) implementation is the simplest technique for enforcing access controls to web resources because it does not require cookies, session identifiers, or login pages; rather, HTTP Basic authentication uses standard fields in the HTTP header.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Margart Wisoky

Last Updated:

Views: 6123

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Margart Wisoky

Birthday: 1993-05-13

Address: 2113 Abernathy Knoll, New Tamerafurt, CT 66893-2169

Phone: +25815234346805

Job: Central Developer

Hobby: Machining, Pottery, Rafting, Cosplaying, Jogging, Taekwondo, Scouting

Introduction: My name is Margart Wisoky, I am a gorgeous, shiny, successful, beautiful, adventurous, excited, pleasant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.