Passwords vs Passkeys - Chalkline (2024)

Passwords vs Passkeys

Passwords are the most used method of authentication, but they are also one of the weakest. Passwords are often easy to guess or steal. Also, many people use the same password across several accounts. This makes them vulnerable to cyber-attacks.

The sheer volume of passwords that people need to remember is large. This leads to habits that make it easier for criminals to breach passwords. Such as creating weak passwords and storing passwords in a non-secure way.

61% of all data breaches involve stolen or hacked login credentials.

In recent years a better solution has emerged – passkeys. Passkeys are more secure than passwords. They also provide a more convenient way of logging into your accounts.

What is Passkey Authentication?

Passkeys work by generating a unique code for each login attempt. This code is then validated by the server. This code is created using a combination of information about the user and the device they are using to log in.

You can think of passkeys as a digital credential. A passkey allows someone to authenticate in a web service or a cloud-based account. There is no need to enter a username and password.

This authentication technology leverages Web Authentication (WebAuthn). This is a core component of FIDO2, an authentication protocol. Instead of using a unique password, it uses public-key cryptography for user verification.

The user’s device stores the authentication key. This can be a computer, mobile device, or security key device. It is then used by sites that have passkeys enabled to log the user in.

Advantages of using Passkeys instead of Passwords

More Secure

One advantage of passkeys is that they are more secure than passwords. Passkeys are more difficult to hack. This is true especially if the key generates from a combination of biometric and device data.

Biometric data can include things like facial recognition or fingerprint scans. Device information can include things like the device’s MAC address or location. This makes it much harder for hackers to gain access to your accounts.

More Convenient

Another advantage of passkeys over passwords is that they are more convenient. With password authentication, users often must remember many complex passwords. This can be difficult and time-consuming.

Forgetting passwords is common and doing a reset can slow an employee down. Each time a person has to reset their password, it takes an average of three minutes and 46 seconds.

Passkeys erase this problem by providing a single code. You can use that same code across all your accounts. This makes it much easier to log in to your accounts. It also reduces the likelihood of forgetting or misplacing your password.

Phishing-Resistant

Credential phishing scams are prevalent. Scammers send emails that tell a user something is wrong with their account. They click on a link that takes them to a disguised login page created to steal their username and password.

When a user is authenticating with a passkey instead, this won’t work on them. Even if a hacker had a user’s password, it wouldn’t matter. They would need the device passkey authentication to breach the account.

Disadvantages to Using Passkeys

Passkeys are definitely looking like the future of authentication technology. But there are some issues that you may run into when adopting them right now.

Passkeys Aren’t Yet Widely Adopted

One of the main disadvantages is that passkeys are not yet widely adopted. Many websites and cloud services still rely on passwords. They don’t have passkey capability yet.

This means that users may have to continue using passwords for some accounts. At least until passkeys become more widely adopted. It could be slightly awkward to use passkeys for some accounts and passwords for others.

Passkeys Need Extra Hardware & Software

One thing about passwords is that they’re free and easy to use. You simply make them up as you sign up for a site.

Passkeys need extra hardware and software to generate and validate the codes. This can be costly for businesses to put in place at first. But there is potential savings from improved security and user experience. These benefits can outweigh the cost of passkeys.

Prepare Now for the Future of Authentication

Passkeys are a more secure and convenient alternative to passwords. They are more difficult to hack, and they provide a more convenient way of logging into your accounts. But passkeys are not yet widely adopted. Additionally, businesses may need to budget for implementation.

Despite these challenges, passkeys represent a promising solution. Specifically, to the problem of weak passwords. They have the potential to improve cybersecurity. As well as boost productivity for businesses and individuals alike.

Need Help Improving Your Identity & Account Security?

Take advantage of the new passkey authentication by exploring it now. It’s the perfect time to ease in and begin putting it in place for your organization.

Give us a call today to schedule a consultation.

FAQ

What is a Passkey?

Passkeys work by generating a unique code for each login attempt. The server then validates this code. This code is created using a combination of information about the user and the device they are using to log in.

What’s the difference between Passwords and Passkeys?

Passwords are a secret word or phrase created by a user that must be used to gain admission to a place whereas Passkeys work by generating a unique code for each login attempt. The server then validates this code. This code is created using a combination of information about the user and the device they are using to log in.

What are the advantages of using Passkeys?

The advantages of using Passkeys include: they are more secure than Passwords, they are more convenient than using Passwords and they are phishing resistant.

What are the disadvantages of using Passkeys?

The disadvantages of using Passkeys include: they are not yet widely adopted, they need extra software and hardware, and they can be costly, and businesses may need to budget for implementation.

Article used with permission from The Technology Press.

Passwords vs Passkeys - Chalkline (2024)

FAQs

Are passkeys really better than passwords? ›

This distinction is backed up by data from Google, which revealed that while passwords have an average success rate of 13.8% on the platform, passkeys were successful 63.8% of the time.

What are the downsides of passkeys? ›

Many websites haven't adopted passkeys, meaning traditional passwords remain necessary. Additionally, passkey compatibility is limited to modern devices with the latest operating systems. This leaves users of older devices at a disadvantage, as their technology may never be updated to support passkeys.

Will passkeys replace passwords? ›

Notably, the era of traditional passwords is coming to an end and organizations' are increasingly recognizing the need for more secure and user-friendly authentication methods. Passkeys offer a promising alternative to passwords, providing enhanced security and usability for users.

Is passkey safer than two-step verification? ›

Gibson, a renowned security expert, emphatically stated that in a properly implemented system, passkeys alone provide far more security than even the strongest password combined with any second authentication factor.

Can passkey be hacked? ›

If someone gets your device, they can't do anything with your passkey. And if you lose your old device containing your passkey, you can easily create a new passkey on your new device.

Can I still use a password if I have a passkey? ›

You can have a passkey and password for the same app or website, and find them both under the same account in Settings > Passwords. You can also save a passkey to a hardware security key.

Do any password managers support passkeys? ›

All the big operating systems, as well as third party password managers such as Dashlane, 1Password, and Bitwarden all support passkeys.

Does Amazon use passkeys? ›

Passkeys are a convenient and secure way to sign in to your Amazon account without using a password. With passkeys, you can sign in to your Amazon account by simply using your face, fingerprint, or the PIN that you use to unlock your device. You will not need to provide your Amazon password to sign in.

What happens to passkeys if you lose your device? ›

However, it's also important that passkeys be recoverable even in the event that all associated devices are lost. Passkeys can be recovered through iCloud keychain escrow, which is also protected against brute-force attacks, even by Apple.

Are passkeys phishing-resistant? ›

The private key is never revealed in the process. Unlike passwords, passkeys are phishing-resistant by design because they're built on the WebAuthn standard.

How do passkeys stop phishing? ›

Passkeys use public-key cryptography and are bound to the origin, preventing phishing. FIDO2 security keys use origin-bound keys and challenge-response, making them phishing-resistant. Smart cards use secure elements and are resistant to phishing.

Do I still need 2FA with passkeys? ›

Do I need 2FA with my passkey? No, because 2FA is built into the passkey that is provided to the website during the login process. Each website may choose to include an additional step for logging in, though most do not.

Can passkeys be stolen? ›

Passkeys also can't be stolen in a data breach. Only the public key is stored on an app or website's server, and it's useless without the corresponding private key. Without physical access to your device (and a way to unlock it), no one can log in to your passkey-protected accounts.

Do I need a password manager with passkeys? ›

While passkeys may eventually replace passwords, they won't replace password managers. Instead, password managers will become even more important. This is because passkeys are tied to an authenticator.

Are passkeys phishing resistant? ›

The private key is never revealed in the process. Unlike passwords, passkeys are phishing-resistant by design because they're built on the WebAuthn standard.

What are the benefits of passkeys? ›

Passkeys are a highly secure form of passwordless authentication that are typically unlocked using methods consumers already use to unlock their devices, like Face ID, Android fingerprint or Windows Hello.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Otha Schamberger

Last Updated:

Views: 5791

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Otha Schamberger

Birthday: 1999-08-15

Address: Suite 490 606 Hammes Ferry, Carterhaven, IL 62290

Phone: +8557035444877

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: Fishing, Flying, Jewelry making, Digital arts, Sand art, Parkour, tabletop games

Introduction: My name is Otha Schamberger, I am a vast, good, healthy, cheerful, energetic, gorgeous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.