Byzantine Generals' Problem | Ledger (2024)

May 21, 2023 | Updated May 24, 2023

The Byzantine Generals’ Problem is a game theory problem that illustrates how difficult it is for decentralized parties to arrive at a consensus or agree on a single truth without relying on a trusted third party.

What is the Byzantine Generals’ Problem?

The Byzantine Generals’ Problem is a classic game theory problem that has become particularly appropriate for decentralized networks and blockchain.

The problem derives its name from the ancient city Byzantium, which had complex communication and defense systems. The problem is set during an attack on an enemy city, when the generals have to coordinate a joint attack. In the problem, the generals can only communicate with each other through messengers for a course of action. However, some of the messengers or generals may be traitors who might deliver false information, which would lead to a failed attack. The goal is to find a way for the loyal generals to arrive at a consensus despite the possibility of conflicting messages from traitors.

The problem arises because the generals cannot trust their messengers to deliver accurate information. In the context of decentralized systems, the Byzantine Generals’ Problem demonstrates the difficulty in coordinating network users in a trustless environment to come to a common consensus. This is because nodes, which are anonymous and could theoretically be malicious, have to trust each other to arrive at a consensus on a shared ledger.

How does Blockchain Solve the Byzantine Generals’ Problem?

Blockchain technology solves the Byzantine Generals’ Problem through protocols that use fault-tolerant mechanisms like proof-of-work (PoW), proof-of-stake (PoS), and delegated proof-of-stake (DPoS) mechanisms. Blockchains create a layer of trust through a consensus mechanism, where the participating nodes have a copy of the ledger. Every transaction has to be verified by a majority of the nodes for it to be added to the ledger, creating a tamper-proof record of all the information on the network. In addition, blockchains utilize cryptographic methods for encryption to ensure the security of transactions or information within the network.

For example, Bitcoin addresses the problem by using a blockchain network to hold all transaction history in a public and trustless manner, where all participating nodes have to agree on the transactions that occurred and in the order in which they occurred. Several cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin, use the proof-of-work mechanism that requires nodes (who represent the generals) to solve a mathematical puzzle in order to add new blocks to the blockchain. The amount of computational work required makes it difficult for a single node to manipulate the blockchain’s history.

Byzantine Generals' Problem | Ledger (2024)

FAQs

Byzantine Generals' Problem | Ledger? ›

The Byzantine Generals' Problem is a game theory problem that illustrates how difficult it is for decentralized parties to arrive at a consensus or agree on a single truth without relying on a trusted third party.

What is the Byzantine commander problem? ›

The Byzantine Generals' Problem is a game theory problem used to describe the challenges of reaching consensus in distributed networks. Theoretical generals are trying to attack a city but need a way to communicate securely to coordinate a successful attack.

What is the Byzantine Generals Problem for dummies? ›

The Byzantine generals are based on a game theory analogy. The problem is that multiple generals besiege Byzantium. They've encircled the city, but they must decide when to assault as a group. They will win if all generals assault simultaneously; however, they will lose if they attack.

How did Satoshi solve the Byzantine Generals Problem? ›

Bitcoin, created by Satoshi Nakamoto, is the first time a decentralized currency has successfully solved the Byzantine Generals' Problem. Satoshi does this using the proof-of-work consensus method. In addition, Bitcoin is the first decentralized system to achieve BFT (Byzantine Fault Tolerance).

What is the Byzantine Generals Problem and how is it relevant to blockchain? ›

The Byzantine Generals problem is a theoretical challenge for describing the difficulty of achieving consensus in decentralized systems. This problem was first solved by Bitcoin through its Proof-of-Work (PoW) consensus mechanism, which sets the standard for consensus in decentralized systems.

Why are Byzantine generals a problem? ›

The Byzantine Generals Problem is a game theory problem, which describes the difficulty decentralized parties have in arriving at consensus without relying on a trusted central party. In a network where no member can verify the identity of other members, how can members collectively agree on a certain truth?

What is the Byzantine Generals Problem game theory? ›

The Byzantine Generals Problem is a game theory problem that reveals the challenges of achieving consensus among a group of mutually suspicious entities using unreliable communication channels. Game theory refers to the best strategy adopted by independent and competing actors in decision-making.

How to solve Byzantine generals problem? ›

To address the Byzantine Generals Problem, honest nodes must achieve consensus even with dishonest nodes in the mix. This implies that a majority of nodes must set a rule framework and agree on its enforcement within the network.

What is the Byzantine generals paradox? ›

The term takes its name from an allegory, the "Byzantine generals problem", developed to describe a situation in which, to avoid catastrophic failure of the system, the system's actors must agree on a concerted strategy, but some of these actors are unreliable.

What problems led to the downfall of the Byzantine Empire? ›

However, these gains were short-lived. Over the subsequent centuries, the Byzantine Empire shrank to a small sliver of its former expanse. This was driven by a wide variety of problems, including civil wars, defeats in wars, economic problems, and religious divisions.

Does Bitcoin solve the Byzantine Generals Problem? ›

Its groundbreaking solution to the Byzantine Generals' Problem established a foundation of trust and decentralized consensus, unlike any digital currency before it. Bitcoin's finite nature, mirroring precious metals, and its pioneering role in the crypto world solidify its status.

What is proof of stake in Byzantine Generals Problem? ›

Proof of Stake (PoS) is an alternative consensus algorithm to Proof of Work (PoW). Unlike PoW where new transactions are confirmed through mining on powerful computers, PoS sees users pledge (or 'stake') their existing assets to validate new transactions.

Was the Byzantine Empire corrupt? ›

The emperor made nominations for court honors and administrative offices, which were often purchased and yielded the largest sums. This government system was also impacted by corruption and loyal relationships between men.

What is the solution to the Byzantine agreement problem? ›

In conclusion, the Byzantine agreement problem remains a significant challenge in distributed systems. The BFT algorithm provides a solution to the problem by allowing nodes to reach a consensus even in the presence of Byzantine nodes.

Who was the best Byzantine general? ›

Belisarius (born c. 505, Germania, Illyria? —died March 565) was a Byzantine general, the leading military figure in the age of the Byzantine emperor Justinian I (527–565).

Does blockchain solve the two generals problem? ›

In summary, blockchain consensus mechanisms address the Byzantine Generals' Problem by leveraging decentralization, cryptographic techniques, and consensus algorithms to ensure the distributed system's secure and consistent state. This makes it difficult for malicious actors to compromise the integrity of the system.

What is the Byzantine emperor problem? ›

The term takes its name from an allegory, the "Byzantine generals problem", developed to describe a situation in which, to avoid catastrophic failure of the system, the system's actors must agree on a concerted strategy, but some of these actors are unreliable.

What was the problem with the Byzantine Empire? ›

However, these gains were short-lived. Over the subsequent centuries, the Byzantine Empire shrank to a small sliver of its former expanse. This was driven by a wide variety of problems, including civil wars, defeats in wars, economic problems, and religious divisions.

What is the Byzantine Generals problem implementation? ›

Thus, the Byzantine Generals problem states that all non-traitorous allied generals must decide together as a whole to either attack or retreat. A failure to come a single conclusive decision for all such generals results in an uncoordinated attack where some generals attacks and some retreat.

What is the Byzantine Generals problem medium? ›

The Byzantine Generals Problem is a signal for distributed systems engineers and architects to take up arms. It serves as a reminder that reaching consensus in a networked environment where components may malfunction or act maliciously is a riddle requiring creative solutions.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Prof. An Powlowski

Last Updated:

Views: 6057

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Prof. An Powlowski

Birthday: 1992-09-29

Address: Apt. 994 8891 Orval Hill, Brittnyburgh, AZ 41023-0398

Phone: +26417467956738

Job: District Marketing Strategist

Hobby: Embroidery, Bodybuilding, Motor sports, Amateur radio, Wood carving, Whittling, Air sports

Introduction: My name is Prof. An Powlowski, I am a charming, helpful, attractive, good, graceful, thoughtful, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.